SEO

SEO Keywords: How to Choose the Ones That Bring Customers

How to choose SEO keywords that bring customers: sort by search intent, score keywords on business value, give each page one primary keyword, and place it without stuffing.

Laptop displaying an analytics dashboard with charts in a bright office

Most small business sites that “do SEO” are ranking for the wrong things. A plumbing company gets traffic for “why is my toilet gurgling”, the phone stays quiet, and someone concludes SEO doesn’t work. The traffic was real. The SEO keywords were chosen for volume instead of for the person who pays.

Below is the decision process we use to pick keywords for a service business, ending with a keyword map for a plumbing company in Calgary.

What are SEO keywords?

SEO keywords are the words and phrases people type (or say) into a search engine that you want a specific page on your site to show up for. The keyword is shorthand for a need. “Plumber near me” and “how to unclog a drain” are both plumbing keywords, but only one of them comes from someone ready to book.

Google no longer matches pages to exact keyword strings. It works out what the searcher wants, so “hot water tank replacement” and “water heater replacement” often return the same results. And the old meta keywords tag does nothing for Google ranking; you can leave it empty in Rank Math or Yoast.

Start with keyword intent, not search volume

Keyword intent is the reason behind a search, and it decides what kind of page can rank and whether the visitor can become a customer. Sort every keyword into one of four buckets before you look at a single volume number.

IntentWhat the searcher wantsExample queries (service business)Page that ranks
InformationalTo understand or fix something themselves“why does my hot water run out fast”, “what does an accountant do for a small business”Blog post, guide
CommercialTo compare options before deciding“tankless vs tank water heater cost”, “CPA vs bookkeeper for LLC”Comparison guide, pricing page
TransactionalTo hire or buy now“water heater installation”, “small business tax preparation services”Service page
LocalA provider nearby, often urgently“emergency plumber calgary”, “accountant near me columbus ohio”Service or location page plus Google Business Profile

To confirm intent, search the keyword in an incognito window and look at what ranks. If page one is all blog posts, Google has decided the searcher wants information, and your service page will struggle there. If you see a map pack with three businesses, the intent is local and your local SEO and Google Business Profile matter as much as the page itself.

Informational keywords still build topical depth and earn links. Just don’t count them as lead generators.

How to choose keywords for SEO: a scoring table

Judge each keyword on four things: business value, intent match, difficulty, and volume, in that order. Volume comes last because a keyword with 30 searches a month from people ready to hire beats one with 3,000 from people who will never buy.

Score each factor 1 to 3 and count business value twice. It’s crude on purpose: it forces a decision.

FactorScore 3Score 2Score 1
Business value (x2)Searcher could hire you for a profitable serviceRelated to what you sell, lower valueRelevant topic, no realistic sale
Intent matchTransactional or localCommercialInformational
DifficultyPage one is local businesses and thin pagesMix of local sites and directoriesPage one is Home Depot, Yelp, national brands
VolumeClearly steady demand in your marketSome demandLittle or none shown, but people do ask

Anything scoring 12 or more (out of 15) gets its own page. Between 9 and 11 is a supporting blog post or a section on an existing page. Below 9, park it.

Difficulty scores from Semrush and Ahrefs lean heavily on backlinks to the top results. For local service keywords they often overstate the challenge, because the real competition is three other plumbers with weak sites. Check the actual results before trusting the number.

Where the keyword ideas come from

  • Google Search Console, Performance report, Queries tab. The best source you have, because these are searches you already appear for. Filter to queries with impressions but an average position between 8 and 30: Google already associates you with them, and a better page can move them.
  • Google Keyword Planner. Free inside Google Ads. Without active ad spend it shows volume in wide ranges, so use it for ideas and rough demand, not precise numbers. You can set the location to a single city or province, which matters for local businesses.
  • Semrush or Ahrefs. Best for competitor gaps: enter a competing plumber’s domain and see which service keywords they rank for that you don’t. Volume for smaller Canadian cities is often missing, so treat a blank as “unknown”, not “zero”.
  • Google autocomplete and People Also Ask. Type the start of a query and note the suggestions, then open the People Also Ask box on the results page. This is where long tail keywords and the exact wording customers use show up.
  • Your phone calls. Ask whoever answers the phone what customers say in the first ten seconds. Those are keywords.

Long tail keywords are where service businesses win

Long tail keywords are longer, more specific searches like “sump pump replacement calgary nw” instead of “plumber”. Each has small volume, but the specificity tells you exactly what the person needs, and a page that answers it clearly tends to rank and convert better than a generic one.

Regional wording matters here, and tools won’t always flag it. Calgarians tend to say “hot water tank” where many Americans say “water heater”. A Canadian business owner may still search “chartered accountant”, the designation that predates CPA in Canada, while an Ohio client simply types “CPA”. And if you serve Quebec, French keywords need their own research. Translating your English list misses how people there actually search.

How many keywords per page? One primary, plus its close variants

Each page should target one primary keyword and the close variants that share its intent. One page can rank for dozens of keywords, but only when Google sees them as the same question. When it doesn’t, splitting them across two pages is the only way either will rank well.

Here’s the honest test. Search both keywords. If the top ten results are mostly the same URLs, one page can win both. If the results are different, Google reads them as different needs, and you need two pages.

  • Same page works: “emergency plumber calgary”, “24 hour plumber calgary”, “after hours plumber calgary”. Same need, same results.
  • Same page fails: “hot water tank replacement calgary” and “hot water tank replacement cost”. The first returns local service pages. The second often returns cost guides and national sites. One page trying to be both usually ends up as neither.

The more common mistake runs the other way. People build a separate page for every variant (“plumber calgary”, “calgary plumber”, “plumbing services calgary”) because the keyword tool listed each as its own row, and a separate row looks like a separate opportunity. Those pages compete with each other. That’s keyword cannibalisation: Google swaps which one it shows, none builds strength, and Search Console shows several URLs flickering for the same query. Merge them into one page and redirect the rest.

Where to put SEO keywords on the page

Put the primary keyword in the title tag, H1, URL slug and the first paragraph, and work it or a variant into the meta description. After that, write for the reader and let variants appear where they fit. Google’s spam policies name keyword stuffing explicitly, and it reads badly to humans anyway.

LocationWhat to doExample (emergency plumber page)
Title tagKeyword near the start, plus a reason to click. Aim for roughly 50 to 60 characters so it isn’t cut off.Emergency Plumber Calgary | 24/7 Response, Upfront Pricing
Meta descriptionNot a ranking factor, but it affects clicks. Say what the page offers and include the keyword naturally.Burst pipe or no hot water? Licensed Calgary plumbers available around the clock. See response areas and call-out rates.
H1Matches the topic of the title, can be slightly plainer.Emergency Plumbing in Calgary
URLShort, readable, keyword included, no dates./emergency-plumber-calgary/
IntroUse the keyword in the first 100 words while answering the main question.“If you need an emergency plumber in Calgary tonight…”
Image alt textDescribe the image accurately. Include the keyword only if it truly describes the image.“Plumber replacing a burst copper pipe under a kitchen sink”

On SEO titles and descriptions: Google rewrites both when it thinks something else on the page fits the query better. Its title link documentation lists the sources it uses, including the H1 and other headings. Keep the title, H1 and opening paragraph telling the same story; if Google keeps rewriting your title, the title probably doesn’t match the page.

How AI Overviews change which keywords are worth targeting

AI Overviews show up mostly on informational searches, and when they answer the question fully, fewer people click through. That lowers the value of simple “what is” and “how to” keywords for lead generation and raises the relative value of local and transactional keywords, where people still want a business, not a paragraph.

Informational content isn’t dead. Google’s guidance on AI features and your website says pages linked from AI Overviews are chosen from pages that are indexed and eligible to appear in Search, with no special markup required. Being cited puts your brand in front of someone early, which matters for an accounting firm: the person reading about S corp elections in the fall may be hiring a CPA before tax season.

How this changes our scoring:

  • Check the live results for each candidate keyword. If an AI Overview answers it completely in two sentences, drop the intent score by one.
  • Favour questions that need judgment, local detail or a professional (“do I need a permit to replace a hot water tank in Calgary”) over ones with a single fixed answer.
  • Write answer-first paragraphs under clear headings, so the page is easy to quote if it’s chosen as a source.

Our guide to ranking in Google AI Overviews goes deeper on structure, and the piece on E-E-A-T and content quality covers why first-hand experience matters more on these pages than keyword placement.

There’s a trade-off we haven’t solved neatly. Informational posts rank more cheaply and produce bigger traffic numbers. Service pages are slower and bring fewer visits, but that’s where revenue comes from. If your reporting rewards sessions, you’ll drift toward the wrong keywords. We’d rather report calls and form fills per landing page, even when the numbers look smaller.

Worked example: a keyword map for a Calgary plumbing company

A keyword map assigns one primary keyword to each page and lists the variants that page should also cover. Below is how we’d sketch one for a residential plumbing company in Calgary. Scores are judgment calls from the table above, not tool data.

PagePrimary keywordClose variants on the same pageIntentScore
/emergency-plumber-calgary/emergency plumber calgary24 hour plumber calgary, after hours plumberLocal14
/hot-water-tank-replacement-calgary/hot water tank replacement calgarywater heater replacement calgary, hot water tank installationTransactional / local14
/drain-cleaning-calgary/drain cleaning calgaryclogged drain plumber, main sewer line cleaningTransactional / local13
/sump-pump-installation-calgary/sump pump installation calgarysump pump replacement, basement flooding pumpTransactional12
/blog/hot-water-tank-cost-calgary/hot water tank replacement costtankless vs tank cost, how long do hot water tanks lastCommercial11
/blog/frozen-pipes-calgary/how to prevent frozen pipessigns of frozen pipes, what to do if pipes freezeInformational9

A few decisions worth explaining:

  • The cost keyword gets its own blog post instead of a section on the service page, because its results look different. The post links to the service page with a plain anchor like “book a hot water tank replacement”.
  • The frozen pipes post scores low, but Calgary winters make it timely and some readers will need a plumber that week. It stays, last in the queue.
  • Neighbourhood pages (“plumber calgary nw”, “plumber airdrie”) only get built if the business genuinely serves those areas and can say something specific about each. Ten near-identical city pages with swapped names are a doorway-page problem, not a keyword strategy.

The same structure works for an accounting firm in Ohio: “small business accountant columbus” and “tax preparation services dayton” as service pages, “s corp vs llc taxes ohio” as a commercial post, and a page on the Ohio Commercial Activity Tax as an informational piece that attracts exactly the business owners the firm wants. If you’d like a second pair of eyes on your own map, our SEO consulting work often starts with exactly this exercise, and our SEO services team can build and track it for you.

Before you publish: a quick checklist

  • Every service you want calls for has one page with one primary keyword.
  • No two pages share a primary keyword. Search your own site with site:yourdomain.com plus the keyword to check.
  • The intent of each keyword matches the page type that already ranks for it.
  • Title, H1, URL and first paragraph all point to the same keyword.

SEO keywords FAQ

What are SEO keywords in simple terms?

They’re the search phrases you want a page to appear for. Good ones describe a need your business can meet, in the words your customers actually use.

How many keywords should I use per page?

One primary keyword, plus any close variants that return mostly the same search results. If two keywords bring up different results, give them different pages.

Are long tail keywords worth targeting if they show zero volume?

Often, yes. Tools under-report searches in smaller US and Canadian markets. If customers ask the question on the phone, people are searching it too.

How long does it take to rank for a new keyword?

It depends on competition and your site’s existing strength. Low-competition local keywords can move within weeks, competitive ones take months. Search Console will show the first impressions before you see clicks.

Can AI tools pick my keywords for me?

They’re good at generating lists and grouping variants, and we use them that way in our AI SEO services. They can’t tell which services make you money or how your customers talk, so the scoring still needs a human who knows the business.

Share LinkedIn X Facebook

Written by

Techlooker Editorial Team

Techlooker helps businesses in the USA and Canada grow through SEO and AI search, WordPress development, Salesforce and Power BI. Our team writes these guides from the work we do for clients.