SEO

How to Do an SEO Audit Yourself (and When to Hire Someone)

How to do an SEO audit with free tools: Search Console, Screaming Frog, PageSpeed Insights and the Rich Results Test, plus a matrix for deciding what to fix first.

Team collaborating on laptops around a shared desk in a modern office

You can do a useful SEO audit yourself in an afternoon with free tools. The hard part is not finding problems. Every tool will hand you hundreds. The hard part is knowing which five actually cost you traffic and leads. This guide shows how to do an SEO audit in the order we work: confirm Google can see the site, find where you are losing, check the pages that matter, then rank the fixes. At the end there is an honest section on when the DIY version stops being enough.

What you need: access to Google Search Console (verified for your domain), the free version of Screaming Frog SEO Spider (it crawls up to 500 URLs, which covers most small business sites), PageSpeed Insights, Google’s Rich Results Test, and a spreadsheet. GA4 helps if it is set up with conversions; if it is not, note that as your first finding.

Step 1: Can Google find and index the right pages?

Start in Search Console’s Page indexing report. If important pages are not indexed, nothing else in the audit matters yet.

Google’s Page indexing report documentation explains each status. The ones worth reading closely on a small site:

  • Excluded by “noindex” tag: fine for thank-you pages, a disaster if your service pages are in the list. The classic cause is a staging site setting copied to production, or WordPress’s “Discourage search engines” box left ticked.
  • Crawled, currently not indexed: Google saw the page and decided not to index it. On a small site this usually points to thin or near-duplicate pages, such as city pages that differ only by the city name.
  • Duplicate without user-selected canonical: often URL parameters, http/https or www/non-www versions, or tag and category archives.
  • Not found (404): check whether any of these used to get traffic or links. Those need redirects.

Then compare: how many pages does your XML sitemap list, how many does Screaming Frog find, and how many does Search Console say are indexed? If those three numbers are far apart, you have found your first real problem.

Step 2: Where are you losing traffic?

Open the Performance report in Search Console, set the date range to compare the last three months with the same period a year earlier, and sort pages by the change in clicks. The pages that lost the most are where the audit should focus.

Comparing year over year matters for seasonal businesses. A landscaping company in Ottawa or a tax preparer in Phoenix will see swings that are just the calendar. For each losing page, check the Queries tab: did impressions drop (you lost rankings or demand), or did clicks drop while impressions held (something in the results page is taking the clicks, often an AI Overview, ads or a map pack)? Those two problems have different fixes.

Also note pages with lots of impressions and an average position between roughly 8 and 20. They are your fastest wins later.

Step 3: Crawl the site and read only the important columns

Run Screaming Frog on the whole site and export the internal HTML tab. You are looking for a handful of issues, not the full list of warnings.

CheckWhere in Screaming FrogWhy it matters
Broken internal linksResponse Codes, Client Error (4xx), then InlinksWastes link value and frustrates visitors
Redirect chainsResponse Codes, Redirection (3xx)Slow, and common after migrations
Missing or duplicate titlesPage Titles tabGoogle may rewrite them; pages compete with each other
Multiple or missing H1sH1 tabUsually a theme template issue affecting every page
Noindex or canonical to another URLDirectives and Canonicals tabsPages you want ranked may be telling Google not to
Deep pagesCrawl Depth columnImportant pages more than three or four clicks from the homepage get less attention
Thin pagesWord Count column, sorted low to highA starting point for “crawled, not indexed” pages

Here is the mistake almost everyone makes on their first audit: they export every warning and try to fix all of it. Tools flag things like “meta description over 155 characters” or “H2 missing” on hundreds of pages, and fixing them feels productive. Most of it changes nothing. Only fix tool warnings that affect pages you need to rank, or that point to a site-wide template problem.

Step 4: Check speed and Core Web Vitals on real templates

Test one URL per template in PageSpeed Insights (homepage, a service page, a blog post, a product page if you have them) and look at the field data first. Field data comes from real Chrome users; the lab score below it is a simulation.

Google’s Core Web Vitals documentation covers the three metrics: Largest Contentful Paint, Interaction to Next Paint and Cumulative Layout Shift. Small sites often have no field data because there is not enough traffic, which leaves you with lab numbers. Treat those as a guide, not a grade. A 58 on mobile does not mean you are losing rankings. A hero image that takes four seconds to show on a phone probably does mean you are losing customers, which is the point we make in why site speed is a business problem.

Step 5: Audit your top ten money pages by hand

Pick the ten pages that should bring in leads or sales, and read each one as a customer would. Tools cannot do this part.

For each page ask: does it target one clear search, does it answer that search in the first screen, is there anything on it a competitor does not have, does it link to related pages, and is the next step obvious? Then search the main query yourself in an incognito window (set to your target city if you are local) and compare the page honestly against the top three results. For local businesses, also check that the Google Business Profile links to the right page; our local SEO strategies guide covers the rest of that side.

Finally, run each template through the Rich Results Test to confirm the schema is valid. Pay attention to errors on LocalBusiness, Product and Article markup. Warnings about optional fields can wait.

Step 6: Prioritize with an impact and effort matrix

Put every real finding in a spreadsheet with two scores, impact and effort, and sort. Do the high-impact, low-effort fixes this week. That is the whole method.

Low effortHigh effort
High impactDo now: remove stray noindex, fix redirects for lost pages with links, rewrite titles on page-two pages, fix broken links in the main menuPlan: merge thin city pages, rewrite off-intent service pages, fix theme speed problems
Low impactBatch later: missing alt text on old posts, long meta descriptionsSkip for now: chasing a perfect lab score, rewriting every old blog post

Impact is a judgment call, and this is where DIY audits often go wrong. A useful test: will this fix change what happens on a page that brings in revenue, or on many pages at once? If neither, it is low impact, however red the tool makes it look.

A one-page SEO audit checklist to copy

If you only keep one thing from this guide, keep this list. Tick each line or write down why it fails.

  • Search Console verified, sitemap submitted, no manual actions
  • Important pages indexed; no stray noindex or wrong canonicals
  • Year-over-year clicks checked by page, losers listed
  • No broken internal links or redirect chains in the main menu
  • Unique titles and one H1 on every money page
  • Core Web Vitals field data checked per template
  • Schema valid on location, product and article templates
  • Top ten money pages compared by hand with the top three results
  • Conversions tracked in GA4 so you can tell if fixes worked
  • Every finding scored for impact and effort

When to hire someone instead

A DIY audit is enough when the site is small, nothing changed recently and you mainly need a to-do list. Bring in help when the cause of a drop is not obvious or the fix needs development work.

Specifically, we would hire help after a site migration or redesign (our website migration SEO checklist shows how much can go wrong), for sites well past 500 URLs, for ecommerce sites with faceted filters, for JavaScript-heavy sites, and for any traffic drop you cannot match to a cause after the steps above. The trade-off is real: an outside audit costs money and an agency will also find more than you need to fix. Ask any auditor to rank their findings by impact and tell you what to ignore. If they cannot, the report will not help you. When that kind of judgment is what you need, our SEO consulting services start with exactly this sort of prioritized audit, and our technical SEO guide goes deeper into crawling and indexing if you want to keep going yourself.

SEO audit FAQ

How long does a website SEO audit take?

For a small business site under 100 pages, an afternoon for the checks and another few hours to prioritize. Larger or ecommerce sites take days.

How often should I run an SEO audit?

A full audit once a year, plus a quick indexing and performance check in Search Console every month, and always after a redesign or migration.

Are free SEO audit tools accurate?

They are accurate about what they measure, but they cannot judge importance. Search Console is the only free source of Google’s own data about your site.

What should an SEO audit checklist include?

Indexing, traffic changes, crawl errors, titles and headings, speed, structured data, and a manual review of your most important pages, followed by a prioritized fix list.

Do I need Ahrefs or Semrush for an audit?

Not for a first audit. They help with backlinks and competitor research, but Search Console and a crawler cover the technical and on-page basics.

Share LinkedIn X Facebook

Written by

Techlooker Editorial Team

Techlooker helps businesses in the USA and Canada grow through SEO and AI search, WordPress development, Salesforce and Power BI. Our team writes these guides from the work we do for clients.